Magic Mixies' toy is harder to get than 'Tickle Me Elmo

Parents say the hottest, hardest-to-find holiday toy this season is the Magic Mixies Magic Cauldron, which retails for $69.99 but is being hawked online for a lot more.

The 24 Best Toys Under $50

Fisher-Price Tickle Me Elmo TMX Extra Special Edition In Original Box!! Rare!!!!

Sesame Street Live! Make Your Magic :: Artists

Sesame Street Tickliest Tickle Me Elmo

From Lincoln Logs to drones: The toys have changed, but holiday excitement still reigns, Features

Elmo's decades-long beef with Zoe's pet rock goes viral again - Upworthy

NEW RARE 2000 Fisher Price Tickle Me Elmo Surprise 5th Anniversary Edition 39442

Just in time for Cyber Monday, red-hot Magic Mixies are back in stock at Walmart

E-SE- TICKLIEST TICKLE ME ELMO

Sesame Street Tickliest Tickle Me Elmo Laughing, Talking, 14-Inch Plush Toy - English Edition

CoComelon Deluxe Interactive JJ Doll Sings Feed Dress me NEW Exclusive 191726412793

Adult TikTok users go WILD for Magic Mixies Magic Cauldron kids' toy

Move aside Tickle Me Elmo, here's this year's hottest toy

Magic Mixies Mixlings - License 2 Play – The Red Balloon Toy Store

Magic Mixies Magic Genie Lamp - Starlight Magic (Target Exclusive)

Magic Mixies Pixlings Flitta the Butterfly Pixling 6.5 inch Doll Inside a Potion Bottle, Ages 5+

Moose Toys Magic Mixies Water Gem Surprise Cauldron, Color: Water - JCPenney

Magic Mixies Mixlings Mystery Collectors Cauldron - Sealed Case of 18